Should we use a VRF air conditioning system or an air-cooled modular unit system for winter heating?
There's no absolute superiority or inferiority between VRF and air-cooled modular chillers for winter heating; the key factors are your building type, usage habits, and climate zone. Simply put: if you have many rooms, staggered room usage times, and require independent control, choose a VRF system ; if you have large spaces, require centralized heating, have high comfort requirements, or live in a frigid region, air-cooled modular chillers (especially enthalpy-increasing models) are a more reliable choice.
I. Core Differences and Winter Heating Performance
VRF multi-split system (fluorine system):
Winter heating characteristics: Fast heating response because the refrigerant directly exchanges heat, eliminating the need to preheat water. High partial load efficiency, suitable for scenarios where only a few rooms require heating.
Low-temperature performance degradation and countermeasures: Standard models experience significant heating capacity degradation at low temperatures. However, in extremely cold regions, VRF units employing quasi-two-stage compression or jet enthalpy enhancement technology can operate at temperatures as low as -22.5°C or even lower; however, attention should be paid to heat fluctuations caused by defrosting.
Comfort: The air outlet temperature is relatively high and dry, and the feeling after long-term use is not as gentle as that of the water system.
Main risks: The system has long piping and many solder joints, which poses a risk of refrigerant leakage, and the failure of the outdoor unit may paralyze the entire system.
Air-cooled modular chiller (water system):
Winter heating characteristics: The water system has a large heat capacity, gentle airflow, and prevents indoor dryness, resulting in high comfort. However, the start-up response is slow, as the water in the pipes needs to be heated first.
Low-temperature performance degradation and solutions: Ordinary models may only retain 50-60% of their heating capacity at -15℃. It is strongly recommended to choose a low-temperature, high-heat model with vapor injection enthalpy enhancement. These models can still operate stably at -20℃, with an outlet water temperature exceeding 55℃, and can power radiators or underfloor heating.
Reliability: Multiple modules are connected in parallel; if one module fails, the others can still function, demonstrating strong fault tolerance. However, the water system is at risk of freezing, and antifreeze measures (adding antifreeze or electric heating) must be taken during winter shutdowns or power outages.
Terminal compatibility: It can be connected to fan coil units , underfloor heating, and radiators, providing greater flexibility in terminal selection.
II. How to Choose: Selection Decision Recommendations
VRF is preferred if any of the following conditions are met:
1. There are many rooms and the usage time is scattered (such as offices, stores, hotel rooms, some rooms are open during the day and some are open at night).
2. Individual metering and separate electricity billing are required for each household.
3. Only use fan coil heating, do not install underfloor heating.
4. The area is not large (generally <3000㎡), and the owner does not want to do a complicated water system, or manage water pump antifreeze and water treatment.
5. Limited ceiling height, and I don't want to install thick water pipes.
Prioritize air-cooled modular units if any of the following conditions are met:
1. Planning to install underfloor heating (the most typical scenario, VRF requires adding water modules to switch to water, which increases the cost and eliminates its advantages).
2. Large-scale, centralized use (factories, entire floors of offices, clubhouses, most areas are turned on at the same time, providing continuous heating for a long time).
3. I want a gentle, non-drying heating experience and don't like direct hot air blowing.
4. The project covers tens of thousands of square meters and has a centralized cold and heat source. It can be integrated into the building automation and group control system in the future.

If your area has a stable municipal centralized heating system, then directly connecting to the centralized heating system is usually the lowest cost and most hassle-free solution, eliminating the need to agonize over between a VRF system and an air-cooled module . A compromise: Air-cooled and water-cooled system: VRF main unit + water heat exchange module, with a refrigerant fan coil unit in summer and underfloor heating in winter; the cost falls between the two, offering both independent temperature control and underfloor heating comfort.